[mirror_ubuntu-artful-kernel.git] / Documentation / highuid.txt

Notes on the change from 16-bit UIDs to 32-bit UIDs:

- kernel code MUST take into account __kernel_uid_t and __kernel_uid32_t
  when communicating between user and kernel space in an ioctl or data
  structure.

- kernel code should use uid_t and gid_t in kernel-private structures and
  code.

What's left to be done for 32-bit UIDs on all Linux architectures:

- Disk quotas have an interesting limitation that is not related to the
  maximum UID/GID. They are limited by the maximum file size on the
  underlying filesystem, because quota records are written at offsets
  corresponding to the UID in question.
  Further investigation is needed to see if the quota system can cope
  properly with huge UIDs. If it can deal with 64-bit file offsets on all 
  architectures, this should not be a problem.

- Decide whether or not to keep backwards compatibility with the system
  accounting file, or if we should break it as the comments suggest
  (currently, the old 16-bit UID and GID are still written to disk, and
  part of the former pad space is used to store separate 32-bit UID and
  GID)

- Need to validate that OS emulation calls the 16-bit UID
  compatibility syscalls, if the OS being emulated used 16-bit UIDs, or
  uses the 32-bit UID system calls properly otherwise.

  This affects at least:
	iBCS on Intel

	sparc32 emulation on sparc64
	(need to support whatever new 32-bit UID system calls are added to
	sparc32)

- Validate that all filesystems behave properly.

  At present, 32-bit UIDs _should_ work for:
	ext2
	ufs
	isofs
	nfs
	coda
	udf

  Ioctl() fixups have been made for:
	ncpfs
	smbfs

  Filesystems with simple fixups to prevent 16-bit UID wraparound:
	minix
	sysv
	qnx4

  Other filesystems have not been checked yet.

- The ncpfs and smpfs filesystems cannot presently use 32-bit UIDs in
  all ioctl()s. Some new ioctl()s have been added with 32-bit UIDs, but
  more are needed. (as well as new user<->kernel data structures)

- The ELF core dump format only supports 16-bit UIDs on arm, i386, m68k,
  sh, and sparc32. Fixing this is probably not that important, but would
  require adding a new ELF section.

- The ioctl()s used to control the in-kernel NFS server only support
  16-bit UIDs on arm, i386, m68k, sh, and sparc32.

- make sure that the UID mapping feature of AX25 networking works properly
  (it should be safe because it's always used a 32-bit integer to
  communicate between user and kernel)


Chris Wing
wingc@umich.edu

last updated: January 11, 2000
Commit	Line	Data
1da177e4 LT	1	Notes on the change from 16-bit UIDs to 32-bit UIDs:
	2
	3	- kernel code MUST take into account __kernel_uid_t and __kernel_uid32_t
	4	when communicating between user and kernel space in an ioctl or data
	5	structure.
	6
	7	- kernel code should use uid_t and gid_t in kernel-private structures and
	8	code.
	9
	10	What's left to be done for 32-bit UIDs on all Linux architectures:
	11
	12	- Disk quotas have an interesting limitation that is not related to the
	13	maximum UID/GID. They are limited by the maximum file size on the
	14	underlying filesystem, because quota records are written at offsets
	15	corresponding to the UID in question.
	16	Further investigation is needed to see if the quota system can cope
	17	properly with huge UIDs. If it can deal with 64-bit file offsets on all
	18	architectures, this should not be a problem.
	19
	20	- Decide whether or not to keep backwards compatibility with the system
	21	accounting file, or if we should break it as the comments suggest
	22	(currently, the old 16-bit UID and GID are still written to disk, and
	23	part of the former pad space is used to store separate 32-bit UID and
	24	GID)
	25
	26	- Need to validate that OS emulation calls the 16-bit UID
	27	compatibility syscalls, if the OS being emulated used 16-bit UIDs, or
	28	uses the 32-bit UID system calls properly otherwise.
	29
	30	This affects at least:
1da177e4 LT	31	iBCS on Intel
	32
	33	sparc32 emulation on sparc64
	34	(need to support whatever new 32-bit UID system calls are added to
	35	sparc32)
	36
	37	- Validate that all filesystems behave properly.
	38
	39	At present, 32-bit UIDs _should_ work for:
	40	ext2
	41	ufs
	42	isofs
	43	nfs
	44	coda
	45	udf
	46
	47	Ioctl() fixups have been made for:
	48	ncpfs
	49	smbfs
	50
	51	Filesystems with simple fixups to prevent 16-bit UID wraparound:
	52	minix
	53	sysv
	54	qnx4
	55
	56	Other filesystems have not been checked yet.
	57
84eb8d06	58	- The ncpfs and smpfs filesystems cannot presently use 32-bit UIDs in
1da177e4 LT	59	all ioctl()s. Some new ioctl()s have been added with 32-bit UIDs, but
	60	more are needed. (as well as new user<->kernel data structures)
	61
	62	- The ELF core dump format only supports 16-bit UIDs on arm, i386, m68k,
	63	sh, and sparc32. Fixing this is probably not that important, but would
	64	require adding a new ELF section.
	65
	66	- The ioctl()s used to control the in-kernel NFS server only support
	67	16-bit UIDs on arm, i386, m68k, sh, and sparc32.
	68
	69	- make sure that the UID mapping feature of AX25 networking works properly
	70	(it should be safe because it's always used a 32-bit integer to
	71	communicate between user and kernel)
	72
	73
	74	Chris Wing
	75	wingc@umich.edu
	76
	77	last updated: January 11, 2000